Cisco Umbrella DNS Alternative: Replace Umbrella DNS and Inspect HTTPS Too
.jpeg)
Last updated: November 2026
The best Cisco Umbrella DNS alternatives in 2026 are dope.security, an on-device secure web gateway that replaces the DNS layer and also inspects HTTPS; Cisco Secure Access DNS Defense, Cisco's own successor; and DNS filters such as DNSFilter, TitanHQ WebTitan, and Cloudflare Gateway. Umbrella DNS Essentials and DNS Advantage reach end of sale on January 31, 2027 and end of support on January 31, 2029, under Cisco bulletin EOL15975. If you only replace DNS with DNS, you keep DNS's blind spots. dope.security replaces Umbrella DNS on every managed Mac and Windows laptop and adds what a resolver can never see: full URLs, HTTPS content, and which account a user is signed in with.
Disclosure: dope.security makes an on-device secure web gateway and is one of the options compared here. Cisco dates and part numbers come from Cisco's published end-of-life bulletin.
Quick facts: dope.security as an Umbrella DNS replacement
- Policy push in seconds. Policy changes reach every online endpoint through push notifications instead of a 30 to 60 minute polling cycle.
- URL filtering, not just domains. 80+ preconfigured categories, each set to Allow, Warn, or Block, plus custom categories built from your own domain and URL lists.
- Full SSL inspection on the device. HTTPS is decrypted and inspected locally by an HTTP/2 proxy, so decrypted data never sits in a third-party data center.
- Corporate versus personal account control. Cloud Application Control allows corporate Microsoft 365, Google, Box, Dropbox, Salesforce, Slack, and WebEx accounts and blocks personal ones.
- Anti-malware on downloads. Every download is hashed, checked, and blocked if malicious before it reaches the application.
- Keeps enforcing offline. Policies are cached on the device, and Fallback Mode keeps enforcing if the cloud is unreachable.
- Light agent. Mac native plus Windows, under 100 MB of RAM, deployed through Intune, Jamf, or Kandji.
- One-click identity. SSO through OpenID Connect with Microsoft 365 or Google, syncing users and groups from Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Ping, and OneLogin.
Why are Umbrella DNS customers looking for an alternative?
Because Cisco is ending Umbrella DNS. Cisco's end-of-life bulletin EOL15975, announced September 1, 2026, covers Umbrella DNS Essentials (E2SF-U-DNS-ESS), Umbrella DNS Advantage (E2SF-U-DNS-R-ADV), and Umbrella DNS Security for Education. The last day to order is January 31, 2027, the last day to renew is January 31, 2028, and the last date of support is January 31, 2029. Cisco's migration targets are Secure Access DNS Essentials (E3S-SA-DNSESS) and Secure Access DNS Advantage (E3S-SA-DNSA), which Cisco's upgrade documentation calls Secure Access DNS Defense.
Moving to Secure Access DNS Defense is not automatic either. Cisco TAC documentation describes it as a paid migration that requires a purchased Secure Access subscription, a Security Cloud Control organization, and the Umbrella Upgrade Manager. For the full Cisco timeline and every migration step, read the Cisco Umbrella end-of-life migration guide.
What can DNS filtering see, and what does it miss?
A DNS filter sees the domain a device asks to resolve. Nothing more. That makes it fast and easy to deploy across a whole network, and it is why DNS filtering stops short on four things that matter in 2026:
- URL paths. DNS sees drive.google.com, not which folder or file. It cannot allow one path and block another on the same domain.
- HTTPS content. DNS never sees inside the encrypted session, so it cannot inspect a download for malware or an upload for sensitive data.
- Accounts. Corporate and personal ChatGPT, Google, and Microsoft 365 accounts resolve to the same domains. A resolver cannot tell them apart, so it can only allow both or block both.
- Data leaving. DNS has no way to classify what a user pastes into an AI tool or uploads to a file-sharing site.
For years that was an acceptable trade. With most work running in SaaS and AI tools on shared domains, it is now where most of the risk lives. See DNS filtering vs secure web gateway for a deeper breakdown.
What are the best Cisco Umbrella DNS alternatives?
| Alternative | Type | Sees HTTPS and URL paths | Corporate vs personal accounts | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dope.security | On-device SWG | Yes | Yes | Managed Mac and Windows fleets that want more than DNS without a cloud proxy |
| Cisco Secure Access DNS Defense | DNS filter | No | No | Cisco-standardized teams that want the in-family path |
| DNSFilter | DNS filter | No | No | Like-for-like DNS replacement |
| TitanHQ WebTitan | DNS filter | No | No | SMBs and MSPs |
| Cloudflare Gateway (DNS mode) | DNS filter, with optional cloud proxy | Only if you add the cloud proxy | Only with the proxy | Teams already on Cloudflare |
Capabilities change often, so confirm specifics with each vendor during a proof of concept.
1. dope.security: replace the DNS layer on every managed device
dope.security runs a secure web gateway on the endpoint. For an Umbrella DNS customer, that means the same category filtering you have today, applied to full URLs instead of domains, plus SSL inspection, Cloud Application Control, AI Analytics, anti-malware, and Dopamine DLP, all on the laptop with no traffic sent to a data center. It is the only option on this list that closes the DNS blind spots without adding a cloud-proxy detour. The limit: it protects managed Mac and Windows devices, so keep a DNS resolver on the office network for guest Wi-Fi and IoT.
2. Cisco Secure Access DNS Defense: the in-family path
Cisco's named successor. Your content categories and destination lists carry over through Cisco's Upgrade Manager, per Cisco's upgrade documentation. The trade-off is that it is still DNS-layer filtering, so every limit in the section above still applies, and the migration requires buying Secure Access and moving to Security Cloud Control.
3. DNSFilter: a like-for-like DNS swap
DNSFilter is a DNS security and content filtering vendor that positions itself directly against Umbrella. It suits teams that want DNS filtering from a different vendor with minimal change. The trade-off is the DNS ceiling.
4. TitanHQ WebTitan: DNS filtering for SMBs and MSPs
WebTitan targets small businesses and managed service providers with DNS-based web filtering and per-location deployment options. Same DNS trade-off.
5. Cloudflare Gateway: DNS now, proxy later
Cloudflare Gateway can start as DNS filtering on Cloudflare's resolver network and add a cloud proxy later inside Cloudflare One. That path ends at a cloud proxy, so HTTPS inspection happens in Cloudflare's network rather than on the device.
How do Umbrella DNS features map to dope.security?
| Umbrella DNS feature | dope.security equivalent | What you gain |
|---|---|---|
| Content category blocking | 80+ categories with Allow, Warn, and Block | Applies to full URLs, plus a Warn option that coaches users |
| Destination lists | Custom categories from domain and URL lists | URL-level entries, not just domains |
| Security categories (malware, phishing) | Malicious, Phishing, Suspicious, Newly Registered, and Proxy Avoidance categories, plus anti-malware on downloads | File-level malware checks, not just domain reputation |
| Policies per identity | Base Policy, custom policies, user and group exceptions | Policy follows the user on any network |
| Roaming client | dope.endpoint | Full SWG on the device, under 100 MB of RAM |
| App discovery (DNS Advantage) | Shadow IT and AI Analytics | Corporate versus personal account breakdown and data volume per app |
| Block page | Custom block pages | Same experience, more context |
| Reporting | Analytics in dope.console plus SIEM integration | Per-transaction visibility instead of per-query |
| Network identities and unmanaged devices | No equivalent | Keep a DNS resolver for guest Wi-Fi and IoT |
Should you keep any DNS filtering?
Yes, for devices you cannot put an agent on. DNS filtering is still the simplest way to cover guest Wi-Fi, printers, conference room hardware, and IoT. The pattern that works for most Umbrella DNS customers: move every managed laptop to an on-device SWG, where the real risk is, and keep a lightweight DNS resolver on the office network for everything else. That gives you full inspection where people actually work and baseline filtering on the network edge.
How do you replace Umbrella DNS with dope.security?
- Export your Umbrella DNS policy. Pull content category settings, destination lists, and per-identity policies.
- Start the instant trial. Sign in with Microsoft 365 or Google. The trial tenant becomes your production tenant, so nothing is thrown away.
- Recreate policy. Map categories, turn destination lists into custom categories, and add group exceptions. The Base Policy already blocks common categories such as Adult Material, Illegal, Piracy, and Malicious.
- Pilot through MDM. Push the dope.endpoint to a pilot group with Intune, Jamf, or Kandji. Watch the Endpoints view and resolve any SSL inspection errors from the notification panel.
- Turn on what DNS could not do. Enable Cloud Application Control for your SaaS and AI tenants, and start Dopamine DLP in Monitor mode.
- Roll out and retire the Umbrella client. Expand in waves, remove the Umbrella roaming module from each wave, and let the Umbrella DNS term lapse.
Teams have moved fast. Greylock Partners went from first proposal to signed contract in 27 days after finding that Umbrella's DNS-only filtering missed HTTPS traffic, and another Umbrella customer migrated 2,000 machines in two days.
FAQ
What is the best alternative to Cisco Umbrella DNS?
For managed Mac and Windows devices, dope.security replaces Umbrella DNS and adds HTTPS inspection, URL-level filtering, corporate versus personal account control, anti-malware, and DLP on the device. For a like-for-like DNS swap, DNSFilter, TitanHQ WebTitan, and Cloudflare Gateway are the main options. Cisco's own successor is Secure Access DNS Defense.
When does Cisco Umbrella DNS reach end of life?
End of sale is January 31, 2027, the last renewal is January 31, 2028, and the last date of support is January 31, 2029, under Cisco bulletin EOL15975.
What replaces Umbrella DNS Essentials and DNS Advantage?
Cisco maps Umbrella DNS Essentials to Secure Access DNS Essentials (E3S-SA-DNSESS) and Umbrella DNS Advantage to Secure Access DNS Advantage (E3S-SA-DNSA), together called Secure Access DNS Defense.
Can DNS filtering block personal ChatGPT accounts?
No. Personal and enterprise ChatGPT accounts use the same domains, so a DNS filter can only allow or block both. Telling them apart requires inspecting the session, which an SWG with tenant-level control such as dope.security Cloud Application Control does.
Is an on-device SWG harder to deploy than DNS filtering?
Not meaningfully for managed devices. The dope.endpoint deploys silently through Intune, Jamf, or Kandji, and policy pushes to every endpoint in seconds. DNS filtering remains simpler for unmanaged devices, which is why many teams keep both.
Does dope.security replace Umbrella SIG too?
Yes. It replaces both Umbrella DNS and the Umbrella SIG cloud proxy for managed devices, because inspection runs on the endpoint with no traffic backhauled. It does not include ZTNA today.
Replace DNS with something that sees more
You have to replace Umbrella DNS anyway. Replace it with something that sees the whole request. Start a free dope.security trial or book a 20-minute demo.


.jpeg)
.jpeg)
.jpeg)

