Is DNSFilter a Good Cisco Umbrella Alternative?

Is DNSFilter a Good Cisco Umbrella Alternative?

Last updated: November 20, 2026

DNSFilter is a solid DNS filter and a like-for-like swap for Cisco Umbrella DNS, but like Umbrella DNS it filters domains, not full requests. If you need HTTPS inspection, account-level control of ChatGPT and SaaS, and DLP on managed laptops, dope.security's on-device URL filtering is the stronger Cisco Umbrella alternative.

Disclosure: dope.security competes with DNSFilter. We've described DNSFilter using its own public pages, linked below, as of November 2026. If something has changed, tell us and we'll update this post.

Why are Umbrella customers looking at DNSFilter?

Umbrella customers are looking at DNSFilter because Cisco is retiring Umbrella, and DNSFilter is the closest DNS-for-DNS replacement.

Cisco's end-of-life bulletin EOL15975, announced September 1, 2026, covers both Umbrella SIG and Umbrella DNS. The key dates:

  • End of sale: January 31, 2027
  • Last renewal: January 31, 2028
  • Last date of support: January 31, 2029

Cisco's named successor is Cisco Secure Access, with DNS Defense as the DNS tier. So every Umbrella customer faces a migration either way. That raises a simple question: if we have to move anyway, should we move to something that looks like what we already have?

DNSFilter is the most common answer. It's a cloud DNS resolver with a roaming client, category filtering, and a clean console. Its DNSFilter vs. Cisco Umbrella page is written for exactly this buyer.

The better question is what you need your web filter to do in 2027 and beyond. We cover the full timeline in Cisco Umbrella end of life: migrate or switch, and the wider field in our honest comparison of the top 10 Cisco Umbrella alternatives.

What does DNSFilter do well?

DNSFilter does protective DNS well: fast deployment, wide device coverage, published pricing, and strong domain-level threat categorization.

Here's what DNSFilter's own site says, as of November 2026:

  • Flexible deployment. You can point a router, DHCP server, or firewall at DNSFilter, use its DNS relay for private and public requests, filter guest Wi-Fi, or install roaming clients (DNSFilter pricing page).
  • Roaming clients on many platforms. Clients run on Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, and Chrome devices and deploy through MDM or RMM. A mode called DNS PreCheck moves filtering logic onto the device with a transparent proxy and a fail-open design (DNSFilter roaming clients page).
  • Threat and content filtering. DNSFilter uses machine-learning domain categorization, offers 40+ content categories, and includes AppAware for one-click app blocking. It says its malicious domain protection flags threats an average of 10 days sooner than third-party threat feeds.
  • AI visibility at the domain level. Its AI Governance and Controls suite shows which AI services devices resolve and lets admins allow, restrict, or block them by user, device, or site (DNSFilter AI governance page).
  • Published pricing. Core lists at $1.00 per license and Plus at $2.25 per license on annual billing, with monthly minimums of $23 and $62.50. Enterprise is quote-only. There's a 14-day free trial.
  • MSP support. Multi-tenant management, branding, and PSA integrations. DNSFilter says it has 6,000+ MSP partners and protects 57,000+ organizations.

DNSFilter also claims instant policy updates, compared with up to one minute for Umbrella, and higher G2 scores than Umbrella on ease of setup and quality of support. For a team that wants Umbrella DNS without Cisco, those are real advantages. For a cost breakdown, see Cisco Umbrella pricing vs DNSFilter vs dope.security.

Where does DNSFilter hit the same ceiling as Umbrella DNS?

DNSFilter hits the same ceiling as Umbrella DNS because both decide on a domain name before any HTTPS request exists.

A DNS lookup carries a hostname and little else. That's why DNS filtering is fast and works on almost any device. It's also why it can't see these things:

  • URL paths. DNS sees drive.google.com. It can't tell a corporate shared folder from a public link to a malicious file on the same domain.
  • HTTPS content. Resolution happens before the TLS session starts. Nothing inside the encrypted request is visible.
  • Accounts and tenants. Personal and corporate logins to ChatGPT, Microsoft 365, or Google resolve to the same hostnames. DNSFilter says this plainly on its AI governance page: it can't "tell a corporate AI account from a personal login on the same service, because both resolve the same hostname."
  • Uploads and AI prompts. DNSFilter also states that it doesn't read prompts, files, or responses. So there's no DLP on what employees paste into AI tools or upload to personal storage.
  • Malware on trusted domains. Attackers host payloads on GitHub, Dropbox, and Google Drive because security teams can't block those domains. A DNS filter has to allow them, so it never sees the file.

This isn't a DNSFilter flaw. It's how DNS works. Greylock Partners hit the same wall with Umbrella, whose DNS-only filtering missed HTTPS traffic. Greylock replaced Cisco Umbrella with dope.security and went from first proposal to signed contract in 27 days. For the technical breakdown, read DNS filtering vs URL filtering.

How do DNSFilter and dope.security compare?

dope.security inspects full HTTPS requests on the laptop, while DNSFilter and Umbrella DNS filter domain lookups through a cloud resolver.

Capabilitydope.securityDNSFilterCisco Umbrella DNS
Where inspection happensOn the device, through an HTTP/2 proxy. Decrypted data never goes to a third-party data center.DNS lookups, via DNSFilter's anycast resolvers or the roaming clientDNS lookups, via Cisco's cloud resolvers or the roaming module
Sees URL paths and HTTPS contentYes. On-device SSL inspection, 80+ URL categories, custom categories from domains or full URLsNo. Domain level onlyNo. Domain level only
Account and tenant controlYes. Cloud Application Control limits Microsoft 365, Google, Box, Salesforce, Slack, Dropbox, WebEx, ChatGPT, Claude, and GitHub to corporate tenantsNo. DNSFilter says personal and corporate logins share a hostnameNo
DLP on uploads and AI promptsYes. Dopamine DLP uses LLM classification for PII, PCI, PHI, and IP. Files stay on the deviceNo. DNSFilter says it doesn't read prompts or filesNo
Malware protectionHashes every download, plus Malicious, Phishing, and Newly Registered domain categoriesBlocks malicious domains before connectionBlocks malicious domains before connection
Unmanaged devices, guest Wi-Fi, IoTNo. Managed Mac and Windows onlyYes. Network, relay, and guest Wi-Fi deployments cover any device; clients for iOS, Android, and ChromeYes. Network-level DNS covers any device
DeploymentInstant trial is a production tenant; SSO with Microsoft 365 or Google; agent via Intune, Jamf, or KandjiChange network DNS settings; roaming client via MDM or RMMChange network DNS settings; roaming module in Cisco Secure Client
Product statusActiveActiveEnd of sale January 31, 2027; support ends January 31, 2029

DNSFilter details come from its public pages as of November 2026. The short version: DNSFilter wins on breadth of devices and networks. dope.security wins on depth of inspection on the laptops where your data and SaaS sessions live.

When is DNSFilter the right choice?

DNSFilter is the right choice when you need to filter devices and networks where you can't run a full on-device agent.

That includes:

  • Guest Wi-Fi and public networks. DNSFilter bundles guest Wi-Fi filtering into its Plus plan.
  • IoT and shared hardware. Printers, cameras, and conference room gear can't run a web gateway agent, but they all make DNS lookups.
  • Unmanaged and mobile devices. Contractor laptops, BYOD phones, and Chromebooks get coverage from network DNS or DNSFilter's mobile and Chrome clients.
  • A budget DNS baseline. A small team that only needs protective DNS can get it at a published per-license price.
  • MSPs. Multi-tenant management and branding make it easy to run across many small clients.

dope.security doesn't cover those cases today. It runs on managed Mac and Windows laptops only, and it doesn't include ZTNA yet.

That's why many teams pair the two layers. A DNS resolver covers the office network, guest Wi-Fi, and IoT. On-device URL filtering covers managed laptops, where employees open SaaS apps, upload files, and paste data into AI tools. The two layers answer different questions: DNS asks where a device is going, and dope.security asks what the user is actually sending.

How do you replace Umbrella with dope.security?

You replace Umbrella with dope.security by starting a trial, syncing users, rebuilding policy, piloting through MDM, and then retiring the Umbrella client.

  1. Start an instant trial. The trial is a production tenant, so your pilot work carries straight into rollout.
  2. Import users via SSO. Sign in with OpenID Connect through Microsoft 365 or Google, and sync users and groups from Okta, Entra ID, Ping, or OneLogin.
  3. Rebuild categories and destination lists. Map Umbrella content categories to dope.security's 80+ URL categories with Allow, Warn, or Block. Turn Umbrella destination lists into custom categories built from domains or full URLs. Add per-user or per-group exceptions where you need them.
  4. Pilot through MDM. Push the agent to a pilot group with Intune, Jamf, or Kandji. SSL inspection errors show up in the console, and you can bypass a problem app in a few clicks.
  5. Turn on Cloud Application Control and Dopamine DLP in Monitor. Lock Microsoft 365, Google, and other apps to corporate tenants, or use CAC Read Only to allow personal logins while blocking uploads. Run Dopamine DLP in Monitor first so you see what's leaving before you block it. AI Analytics shows personal versus enterprise use of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Copilot.
  6. Roll out and retire the Umbrella client. Expand to every managed laptop, confirm coverage, then remove the Cisco roaming module. Policy changes reach devices in seconds, and the agent uses under 100 MB of RAM. One Umbrella customer migrated 2,000 machines in two days.

Frequently asked questions

Is DNSFilter a good Cisco Umbrella alternative?

Yes, for DNS-layer filtering. DNSFilter is a like-for-like swap for Umbrella DNS, with published pricing and broad device support. It doesn't add HTTPS inspection, tenant control, or DLP, so it won't close the gaps Umbrella DNS already had.

Does DNSFilter inspect HTTPS?

No. DNSFilter filters DNS lookups, which happen before the HTTPS session starts. It sees the domain, not the URL path or the content. Its DNS PreCheck mode runs on the device, but it still filters at the DNS layer.

Can DNSFilter block personal ChatGPT accounts?

No. DNSFilter can allow or block ChatGPT as a service, but its own site says it can't tell a corporate AI account from a personal login because both resolve the same hostname. dope.security's Cloud Application Control restricts ChatGPT to your corporate tenant.

DNSFilter vs dope.security: what's the difference?

DNSFilter is a cloud DNS filter that covers any device on a filtered network. dope.security is an on-device secure web gateway for managed Mac and Windows laptops. It inspects HTTPS, controls SaaS accounts, and runs DLP on uploads and AI prompts.

Do I need both DNSFilter and dope.security?

Many teams run both. Use DNS filtering for guest Wi-Fi, IoT, and unmanaged devices, and dope.security on managed laptops. If nearly all your users work on managed Mac and Windows laptops, dope.security alone may cover what you need.

See what Umbrella DNS was missing. Start a free dope.security trial or book a 20-minute demo.

DNS Filtering
DNS Filtering
Secure Web Gateway
Secure Web Gateway
Comparisons & Alternatives
Comparisons & Alternatives
← back to blog Home